News RSS Feed


999 crew went 51 miles adrift

6:30am Tuesday 4th March 2008

comment Comments (13)   Have your say »

By Matt Wilkinson »

A teenage girl lay dying in a park while an ambulance was mistakenly sent to the wrong town 51 miles away, the Oxford Mail can reveal.

The 14-year-old collapsed and then later stopped breathing after binge drinking vodka in the skate park in Mably Way, Grove near Wantage.

A passer-by dialled 999 for an ambulance but the control centre dispatched a crew two counties away to a skate park in Grove, Leighton Buzzard, Bedfordshire.

It took nearly an hour before paramedics arrived at the right place - after the girl had stopped breathing and had to be resuscitated by Police Community Support Officer Sue Harris.

Oxfordshire merged with Buckinghamshire, Hampshire and Berkshire to form South Central Ambulance Service in July 2006, and all calls are routed through Milton Keynes.

A spokesman for the South Central Ambulance Service said an investigation had been launched.

She said its records had the incident as being in a skate park in Grove near the airfield in Leighton Buzzard, and that is why the case was passed to Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire ambulance.

But Frank Parnell, chairman of Grove Parish Council, said he could not believe the caller in Grove would have told the controllers in Milton Keynes it was in Bedfordshire - two counties away.

He said: "It is ridiculous these calls are being handled by people without local knowledge. It's important they at least know where places are.

"I can't believe anyone can mix the two up.

"They are very far apart and completely different. There is no way anyone could think they were in Leighton Buzzard."

Three quarters of an hour after the first call, PCSOs called for an ambulance after getting concerned about the girl.

Minutes later she stopped breathing and needed to be revived by PSCO Harris.

PCSO Harris said at the time: "We are trained to get on with what is put in front of you and then think about it afterwards."

Police logs showed the ambulance arrived one hour and eight minutes after the initial call. The ambulance service disputes the time of arrival, but not whether the girl had stopped breathing. It is investigating why police logs show different times.

Dr Peter Skolar, a former GP and chairman of Oxfordshire County Council's heath scrutiny committee, said: "We hear about the ambulance service response times but how many times, as in this case, have their ambulances been misrouted?"

Michelle Ullett, spokesman for South Central Ambulance Service, said: "Unfortunately on this occasion there was some confusion over the location of the incident.

"It is essential when members of the public require our assistance that we receive as much information as possible about the patient's location."


Your Say YourOxford

onlyhuman, says...
7:56am Tue 4 Mar 08

it's all about saving money. the victim, as usual, is at the bottom of the ladder. but of course the ambulance service managers really do care, (about performance bonuses) don't they.

responsibilty, says...
9:57am Tue 4 Mar 08

onlyhuman wrote:
it's all about saving money. the victim, as usual, is at the bottom of the ladder. but of course the ambulance service managers really do care, (about performance bonuses) don't they.
Victim?????!!!!!!

rick, _ says...
10:19am Tue 4 Mar 08

Whatever you think about the case of this girl, the mistake could have affected anyone.

Arfur Jock, Oxford says...
10:41am Tue 4 Mar 08

responsibilty wrote:
onlyhuman wrote:
it's all about saving money. the victim, as usual, is at the bottom of the ladder. but of course the ambulance service managers really do care, (about performance bonuses) don't they.
Victim?????!!!!!!
You know nothing about this girl other than she had collapsed due to drinking excess alcohol.
I reckon one in four people I know had one awful night when they were out of control on drink and it turned into a vom-fest.
Children are allowed to make the odd mistake - learning boundaries etc is what growing up is all about.
Don't turn this story into one about the state of the youth today because it ain't.

Anonymous FF, Oxford says...
11:13am Tue 4 Mar 08

This incident demonstrates why the residents of Oxfordshire should fear for their lives when their Fire control room is moved to the South East regional control room which is being built at Fareham in Hampshire.

The new system will see operators in Fareham handling calls and dispatching fire engines for EIGHT counties, and the Isle of Wight. They are unlikely to posess any relevant local knowledge except perhaps for the county in which they live. Oxfordshire's existing control room benefits from a very good level of local knowledge and this will be lost.

Aside from this the project is at a huge cost to the taxpayer and government IT projects nearly always go over budget and are a dismal failure.

Please write to your local MP to try and get this ridiculous idea scrapped before it's too late!

Not Anal Page, says...
11:29am Tue 4 Mar 08

Sat navs eh? Get a map retards!!

Chris, says...
11:47am Tue 4 Mar 08

Not Anal Page wrote:
Sat navs eh? Get a map retards!!
It's nothing to do with sat nav. Regardless of the ambulance having sat nav or a regular map (they carry both by the way), if the wrong ambulance gets sent from completely the wrong county, to the wrong place, something has gone wrong!

Marie, Oxford says...
12:37pm Tue 4 Mar 08

The level of service provided is not always of high standard because the pay is terrible so highly efficient and intelligent people are not prepared to work for the low amount. So instead, less capable people fill in the role thus being taken advantage off and not having proper training (without even realising). Its a vicous circle of problems that affect everyone.

MIKE, oxford says...
12:53pm Tue 4 Mar 08

Marie wrote:
The level of service provided is not always of high standard because the pay is terrible so highly efficient and intelligent people are not prepared to work for the low amount. So instead, less capable people fill in the role thus being taken advantage off and not having proper training (without even realising). Its a vicous circle of problems that affect everyone.
a case of "if you pay peanuts you get monkeys"?? if that is the case why do the monkeys in Whitehall get a fortune?

Tish, Witney says...
1:05pm Tue 4 Mar 08

I've got a condition which means I have to call and Ambulance about twice a year. So far, they haven't let me down and have saved my life on three occassions. Every now and then they get it wrong which makes great media, but is there any chance of a paper covering a story about what good they do as a whole?

olive, oxfordshire says...
2:14pm Tue 4 Mar 08

this is just a PSCO, trying to make herself look good.
because most of the time they ride around on their bikes, making out they are doing something good for our streets.and some of them have real bad attitude.
so well done to you for saving the girls life. so the ambulance service got the wrong place, at least you were there to help her..but it ain't no ones fault that the communication had gone wrong.

Jean Charles de Menezes, 6 feet under in Brazil says...
12:10am Wed 5 Mar 08

I had a similar problem when I called police to Park Street, Woodstock. It took several minutes to convince the stupid call centre operator at Thames Valley Police that Woodstock was indeed in their area. I even had to tell her over the phone where it was on her map! It would almost have been quicker for me to jump in the car, drive to Kidlingtton and pick up a policemen from HQ!

Gemma, says...
6:38pm Wed 5 Mar 08

Marie wrote:
The level of service provided is not always of high standard because the pay is terrible so highly efficient and intelligent people are not prepared to work for the low amount. So instead, less capable people fill in the role thus being taken advantage off and not having proper training (without even realising). Its a vicous circle of problems that affect everyone.
Are many "highly efficient and intelligent people" working for the ambulance service who are capable of doing a fantastic job.
We join the ambulance service to help people not for level of pay! Why the low opinion of people who provide a life saving service?

Your sayYourOxford

comment Add your comment

Register for a FREE Oxford Mail account and you can have your say on today's news and sport by adding comments on articles we publish. The best comments may even get published in the paper.

Please register now or sign in below to continue.




Forgotten your password?

Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »